Fire and Smoke Curtains: Meeting Atrium Code Requirements

Relatively new to the United States, fire and smoke curtains are less complex and less expensive than comparable mechanical systems and support the use of daylighting design.
This course is no longer active
[ Page 3 of 7 ]  previous page Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 Page 5 Page 6 Page 7 next page
Sponsored by Smoke Guard, Inc.
Karin Tetlow

Automatic Sprinkler Systems

Sprinkler systems are de rigueur in response to the IBC code requiring an approved automatic sprinkler system be installed throughout an entire building—including atrium designs (one exception is when that area adjacent to or above the atrium is separated by a 2-hr. fire-resistance fire-rated barrier or horizontal assembly, or both).

Sprinkler systems are designed to control a fire, not to extinguish it. It is therefore likely that significant quantities of smoke may be generated that can travel far from the initial fire source. Since sprinkler systems are not sufficient to protect an atrium from potential smoke migration—codes require the addition of a smoke management system.

Case Study 1: Use of Horizontal Flexible Smoke Curtain in Open Plan Office

This case study demonstrates that multiple components of a mechanical smoke control system could have been replaced by a single passive horizontal smoke control curtain at considerable cost savings.

A four-floor office building was renovated to include a series of floor openings. A skylight extended above the center of the third floor in the area above the atrium opening. Height from the ground floor to skylight was approximately 53 ft. The floor openings were offset and did not line up vertically to provide a typical atrium configuration. This made it difficult to maintain smoke at least 6 ft above the highest occupant. A tenability smoke exhaust control system was therefore proposed based on performance-based requirements developed using a modeling approach.

The intent of the design was to exhaust smoke from the floor containing the fire and from the skylight, also to exhaust smoke that might spill into the atrium. Supply/make-up air was delivered to the two non-fire floors. For a fire directly beneath the atrium opening where smoke would rise unimpeded up into the skylights, beam detectors in the skylights aligned the system to exhaust the uppermost third floor in conjunction with the skylight exhaust.

The skylight exhaust and floor exhaust were accomplished using new, dedicated mechanical equipment. The supply air was provided via a combination of new, dedicated equipment and existing equipment that was also used to provide normal HVAC.

For this project it would have been possible to replace the entire smoke exhaust system by a single horizontal 2-hr. flexible fire curtain at the second floor slab. This would separate the building into two 2-story connected spaces, neither of which would require active/mechanical smoke control. The size of the opening was nominally 20 ft x 60 ft. Activation of the flexible fire barrier would be via the fire alarm control panel upon smoke detection or sprinkler water flow.

Mechanical Smoke Control System Required:

  • Two 50,000 cfm fans
  • Two 30,000 cfm fans
  • Two three-story risers within a common shaft
  • Twelve large fire/smoke dampers (varying sizes)
  • U-shaped distribution ductwork on 3 floors
  • UUKL (specific panel function to ensure compatibility within the smoke control system) smoke control panel/fire fan control panel
  • Associated interlocks/controls/monitoring devices
  • Increase in emergency generator size

Passive Smoke Control System:

  • One 20-ft x 60-ft horizontal smoke curtain having a 2-hr. fire-resistance rating

Top: Cross-sectional view of office showing offset configuration of floor openings; Bottom left: Smoke exhaust control system design; Bottom right: Horizontal flexible smoke curtain at second floor

 

 

[ Page 3 of 7 ]  previous page Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 Page 5 Page 6 Page 7 next page
Originally published in Architectural Record
Originally published in August 2011

Notice

Academies