This CE Center article is no longer eligible for receiving credits.
Formal ceremonies celebrating architecture
are usually reserved for ground breakings, openings, or reopenings,
rarely for closings. But on May 17, 2005, S.R. Crown Hall
at the Illinois Institute of Technology (IIT), designed by
Ludwig Mies van der Rohe and completed in 1956, was closed
for restoration and renovation amid much fanfare. A hundred
or so admirers of the school and the architect convened to
witness a symbolic demolition-the inverse of a ribbon
cutting-to launch the restoration. Mies's grandson,
Chicago architect Dirk Lohan, won the opportunity to smash
one of the 10-foot-tall windows at an online auction on eBay,
sponsored by the Mies van der Rohe Society (mies.iit.edu).
In the audience at the ceremony was Mark
Sexton, AIA, principal of Krueck & Sexton Architects,
the local firm charged with this phase of an ongoing restoration
of Crown Hall and other Mies structures. Sexton admits that
after the sledge hammer shattered the glass and the university
president announced that the reopening would take place in
15 weeks, reality set in, and his heart began to race. Although
an opportunity of a lifetime for any firm, performing reconstructive
surgery on what Time magazine called "one of the world's
most inspiring and astonishing structures" is an undertaking
fraught with danger, suggesting that a tight schedule might
have been the least of Sexton's worries. Crown Hall is
the home of IIT's College of Architecture, where Mies
was director from 1938 until 1958. Thirty-six years after
his death, the faculty still consists of Mies disciples, who,
with a student body of 600, consider themselves conservators
of the masterpiece, which received Chicago landmark status
in 1997 and became a National Landmark in 2001.
 |
Ludwig Mies van der
Rohe circa 1956 standing in S.R. Crown Hall,
the architecture school he designed at the
Illinois Institute of Technology.
Images: Courtesy Krueck & Sexton, except
as noted; Hedrich-Blessing (this page) |
|
|
The weight of "almost nothing"
Unlike earlier Crown Hall renovations
in which the travertine and steel of the South Porch were
replaced and women's bathrooms were added in the basement,
this phase was more complex and intricate. Crown Hall contains
the architectural DNA of Mies's entire aesthetic. The
beauty exists paradoxically in the metaphorical nothingness
of it. The building is a big box, a "one-room school
house," as Dean Donna Robertson, AIA, has called it.
The 120-foot-by-220-foot floor plate seems to hover 6 feet
above grade. Meanwhile, the roof hangs 18 feet above the floor
from an exoskeleton made of four, 6-foot-deep steel girders.
From the inside, the resulting clear-span, "universal
space" experience is that of being in a structure with
no visible means of support. Furthermore, the curtain wall
had enormous expanses of glass held in place by the slimmest
of stops.
Formal ceremonies celebrating architecture
are usually reserved for ground breakings, openings, or reopenings,
rarely for closings. But on May 17, 2005, S.R. Crown Hall
at the Illinois Institute of Technology (IIT), designed by
Ludwig Mies van der Rohe and completed in 1956, was closed
for restoration and renovation amid much fanfare. A hundred
or so admirers of the school and the architect convened to
witness a symbolic demolition-the inverse of a ribbon
cutting-to launch the restoration. Mies's grandson,
Chicago architect Dirk Lohan, won the opportunity to smash
one of the 10-foot-tall windows at an online auction on eBay,
sponsored by the Mies van der Rohe Society (mies.iit.edu).
In the audience at the ceremony was Mark
Sexton, AIA, principal of Krueck & Sexton Architects,
the local firm charged with this phase of an ongoing restoration
of Crown Hall and other Mies structures. Sexton admits that
after the sledge hammer shattered the glass and the university
president announced that the reopening would take place in
15 weeks, reality set in, and his heart began to race. Although
an opportunity of a lifetime for any firm, performing reconstructive
surgery on what Time magazine called "one of the world's
most inspiring and astonishing structures" is an undertaking
fraught with danger, suggesting that a tight schedule might
have been the least of Sexton's worries. Crown Hall is
the home of IIT's College of Architecture, where Mies
was director from 1938 until 1958. Thirty-six years after
his death, the faculty still consists of Mies disciples, who,
with a student body of 600, consider themselves conservators
of the masterpiece, which received Chicago landmark status
in 1997 and became a National Landmark in 2001.
 |
Ludwig Mies van der
Rohe circa 1956 standing in S.R. Crown Hall,
the architecture school he designed at the
Illinois Institute of Technology.
Images: Courtesy Krueck & Sexton, except
as noted; Hedrich-Blessing (this page) |
|
|
The weight of "almost nothing"
Unlike earlier Crown Hall renovations
in which the travertine and steel of the South Porch were
replaced and women's bathrooms were added in the basement,
this phase was more complex and intricate. Crown Hall contains
the architectural DNA of Mies's entire aesthetic. The
beauty exists paradoxically in the metaphorical nothingness
of it. The building is a big box, a "one-room school
house," as Dean Donna Robertson, AIA, has called it.
The 120-foot-by-220-foot floor plate seems to hover 6 feet
above grade. Meanwhile, the roof hangs 18 feet above the floor
from an exoskeleton made of four, 6-foot-deep steel girders.
From the inside, the resulting clear-span, "universal
space" experience is that of being in a structure with
no visible means of support. Furthermore, the curtain wall
had enormous expanses of glass held in place by the slimmest
of stops.
Ronald Krueck, FAIA, and Sexton, both
alumni of IIT, were well aware that the starkness of Mies's
work does not equate to simplicity, nor was his bias in favor
of off-the-shelf components suggest a generic architectural
vocabulary. They were ready to preserve and protect every
detail, adjacency, span, and material. Still, it takes a lot
of research and study to restore "almost nothing."
The architects were fortunate to have the services of preservation
consultant Gunny Harboe, AIA, of Austin AECOM (formerly McClier).
The scope of work was extensive: The
sandblast removal of all lead-based paint from interior and
exterior steel and repairs to the members that had rusted.
The steel hadn't been repainted in 25 years, so the dense
"Miesian black" from photographs had faded to a
dull gray. The glass panels did not conform to any code, so
they had to be replaced, and the steel stops redesigned. The
process also involved refurbishment and reactivation of the
blinds, disassembling and retrofitting them with electromagnetic
release hardware, and refurbishing the original Ellison stainless-steel
doors on the north and south facades. Finally, the $3.6 million
renovation included upgrading the bathrooms to meet current
ADA accessibility standards.
| click
images to view them larger |
 |
 |
 |
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
| Steel
corrosion was extensive. The repair cycle
included sandblasting, inspection, more sandblasting,
and repair. Steel conducted moisture along
the base causing condensation in the winter.
When the paint is damaged by moisture and
exposes the steel to the elements, the steel
rusts and forms a red dust (1 & 2). Corrosion
pits form, which produce just enough pressure
in the stop to crack the glass (2 & 3). |
|
|
Obviously, the restoration didn't
actually take place in 15 weeks, as the closing ceremony pronouncements
suggested. Assessment of the existing conditions, study of
Mies's details, and the final design solution evolved
over a two-year period. The actual demolition and construction
lasted 15 weeks, but when the symbolic shattering took place,
every beam, frame, and pane of glass was already fabricated
and waiting for assembly nearby. The planning process was
methodical, and the execution surgically precise. Much of
the credit for this goes to Clune Construction Company, whose
scheduling and coordination of the demolition, repair, and
reconstruction sequences included a contingency plan for dealing
with and solving unforeseen problems while staying on schedule.
| click
images to view them larger |
 |
 |
 |
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
| Steel
corrosion was extensive. The repair cycle
included sandblasting, inspection, more sandblasting,
and repair. Steel conducted moisture along
the base causing condensation in the winter.
When the paint is damaged by moisture and
exposes the steel to the elements, the steel
rusts and forms a red dust (1 & 2). Corrosion
pits form, which produce just enough pressure
in the stop to crack the glass (2 & 3). |
|
|
The first task was to quickly shroud
the entire building in order to contain dust from the lead-based
paint that was to be sandblasted off all the steel members.
"We divided the building into quadrants," explained
Michael A. Tenuta, senior vice president of Clune Construction.
"Sandblasting the steel was followed by an inspection,
then more sandblasting, then repairs, then another inspection,
then the first of three coats of paint. There was no float
time, and there was a constantly roving punch list."
The sound of glass shattering
"Mies's design was experimental,"
explains Sexton. "At the time, glass technology was in
its infancy, and there were few regulations. Mies relied on
his intuition regarding size." The facade consists of
two types of windows. The original upper panels were enormous
and not tempered-9 feet 8 inches by 12 feet 9 inches-and
only 1¼4 inch thick. With no codes to dictate size
and thickness at the time, Mies was free to push the known
limits of engineering. His experiment had mixed results. Great
expanses of crystal-clear glass poured daylight into the studio
and created the "barely there" effect he sought.
However, "great expanses of glass have a tendency to
break and fall out in strong winds," Sexton adds. (Anecdotal
evidence suggests that no one was ever injured, or at least
not seriously.)
| click
images to view them larger |
 |
 |
 |
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
| The
contractor shrouded the entire building (1)
to keep the dust from the lead-based paint
from escaping into the environment. Students
work at Mies-designed drafting tables in 1956
(2). Mies's grandson, architect Dirk
Lohan (3), ceremoniously launches the restoration
by smashing one of the glass panels. |
|
|
In contrast to the perfectly transparent
upper panels, the lower units were sandblasted, which provided
some privacy for the students, but mostly it served to hide
interior activity from view, and thus retained a pristine
Modernist face to the public. However, the glass was sandblasted
on the interior face. Sandblasted glass is porous and absorbs
oil from fingerprints and the adhesives students used to mount
drawings on the windows. Due to decades of unintentional damage,
the lower units became stained and scratched. In addition,
the building was subjected to ad hoc alterations and mandatory
repairs between 1970 and 1977. In 1975, Skidmore, Ownings
& Merrill (SOM) replaced all the glass, including the
thin upper panels, which were replaced with 3¼8-inch
lites. Then, employing new technology for the lower panels,
SOM installed a laminated glass with a mylar interlayer to
imitate the translucent qualities of the original sandblasted
glass. Although the solution eliminated the staining problem,
the result was more reflective than Mies's matte finish,
and repairing the repair, as it were, presented a perplexing
challenge for Krueck & Sexton.
| click
images to view them larger |
 |
 |
 |
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
| At
least five full-size mock-ups (3) were produced
to test several glazing options and the blind
replacements. Studies of solar radiation transmission
show the difference between laminated glass
units (1) and single sandblasted panes (2). |
|
|
Every solution seemed to create more
problems. The first challenge, and the one that generated
the most controversy, centered on the upper panels. First
of all, the glazed area was too large by code (or common sense)
to have the original 1¼4-inch-thick polished plate
glass replaced. To comply with the code, the architects could
have simply specified 3¼8-inch tempered glass. Keeping
in mind that Mies's details are deceptively simple, Sexton
recognized that tempered glass could be less than perfect.
"When glass passes through an oven during the tempering
phase, it can develop the slightest surface wave from contact
with the rollers," he explains. The waviness can sometimes
be noticeable when viewing reflected images from a distance.
This would be unacceptable to even the most forgiving critic.
Now, 1¼2-inch glass doesn't
have to be tempered, so Sexton was confident that he could
deliver a perfect surface. But, of course, every solution
yields a new problem. In this case, the problem was color.
Iron in glass gives it a green tint, so the thicker the panes,
the greener the tint. Crown Hall was intended to have glass
so clear as to seem barely there, which was possible with
1¼4-inch panes. The architects eventually found a manufacturer
that could make low-iron glass in such large sheets, in order
to achieve maximum transparency, high-fidelity light transmission,
and the kind of brilliance usually reserved for jewelry cases
and museum displays.
The 68 original lites of the upper panels
were replaced with PPG Starphire (low iron) glass, and the
cycle of problems and solutions continued. Thicker glass is
heavier, of course. The new panels weighed 700 pounds, making
them way too heavy for the original stops. In other words,
the stops had to be enlarged from 5¼8 inch to 3¼4
inch in depth. As the wall sections show, this redesign is
subtle enough to be called invisible. However, it has a slope.
The architects felt, and the mock-ups confirmed, that a deeper
reveal would look heavy. Sexton argued that by sloping the
stop from 3¼4 inch at the glass to 5¼8 inch
at face, it would read the same as the original. The purists
rebutted that it would be blasphemous to introduce any amount
of slope in a rigidly rectilinear structure. They also argued
that Mies used off-the-shelf extrusions, and a sloped stop
would have to be custom fabricated, a clear violation of his
principles. Sexton, with the support of Dean Robertson and
Gunny Harboe, prevailed, because they convinced all the interested
parties that, first of all, the slope cannot be seen. And
secondly, compromising on the custom-design issue was better
than specifying a heavy, and thus inappropriate, stock stop.
Clune enlisted specialty-glazing contractor
Harmon to handle the field work and endure the closest scrutiny.
According to Harmon, the facade consists of more than 800
steel stops held in place by more than 6,250 screws, and each
screw was countersunk to protect the ever-so-slightly beveled
profile. Tenuta marvels at the scrutiny. They had to be submitted
for approval, were rejected, remade, and resubmitted. Even
the depth of the countersink was debated, until a tolerance
of a mere 1¼64 inch was agreed upon.
The 120 lower lites were replaced with
a clear tempered glass from Viracon, and the inner face was
sandblasted to recreate the exact same effect as the original.
The Miesian scholars were in agreement with this solution.
However, Sexton knew that unless the sandblasted side was
treated, the school would face the same staining and scratching
problems it did before. Fortunately, technology eliminated
many concerns. Computer-controlled manufacturing allows glass
to be both tempered and sandblasted, and as proved here, to
be protected by the application of three layers of ultra-clear
epoxy, which has no reflectivity, will not change character,
and will never yellow.
 |
| S.R. Crown Hall is
returned to its original glory. Krueck &
Sexton Architects and Clune Construction searched
until they found a manufacturer to recreate
the "Miesian black" that delineates
the structure's exoskeleton in stark
contrast to the rest of the campus. |
 |
|
|
Finally, there was the issue of the paint.
The sharp "Mies black" had faded to a dull gray.
The original paint could not be used again, because it was
lead-based. Product research led the architects to Tnemec,
an industrial paint and coatings manufacturer known for products
of extreme durability. The three coats that were applied should
last about 25 years.
Studying Krueck & Sexton's restoration
and renovation of Crown Hall reveals more about Mies's
design methodology than a slide-show lecture in architecture
school ever could. Its work also makes a convincing argument
for balancing preservation of original intent with current
needs. The great Modernist buildings of the 20th century were
meant to have long, working lives. Modifications to Crown
Hall will be necessary again in another 50 years. As evidenced
by SOM's restoration of Lever House in New York in 2002
and Polshek and Partners' careful restoration of Louis
Kahn's Yale Art Gallery in New Haven, currently under
way, intimate intervention of Modernist icons might be the
only authentic way to know them.