Embodied Carbon & Adaptive Reuse

Carbon Calculus: Architects reduce embodied emissions by revamping existing structures instead of building new.
 
Sponsored by Build with Strength, a coalition of the National Ready Mixed Concrete Association
Architectural Record
By Katharine Logan
 
1 AIA LU/HSW; 0.1 IACET CEU*; 1 AIBD P-CE; AAA 1 Structured Learning Hour; This course can be self-reported to the AANB, as per their CE Guidelines; AAPEI 1 Structured Learning Hour; This course can be self-reported to the AIBC, as per their CE Guidelines.; MAA 1 Structured Learning Hour; This course can be self-reported to the NLAA.; This course can be self-reported to the NSAA; NWTAA 1 Structured Learning Hour; OAA 1 Learning Hour; SAA 1 Hour of Core Learning

Learning Objectives:

  1. Define the term “embodied carbon” and explain why its reduction is critical to mitigating climate change.
  2. Explain why adaptive reuse conserves embodied carbon.
  3. Explain what a life cycle assessment (LCA) is and what impacts it quantifies.
  4. Describe some common LCA tools.

This course is part of the Concrete Academy

[ Page 2 of 2 ]  previous page Page 1 Page 2

The new structure consists of concrete-filled steel-tube columns and steel beams grafted onto the existing concrete framework. To prevent differential settlement of the old and new floor plates from fracturing the slabs, with knock-on damage to the facade, the construction team left a gap of one structural bay between the old and new elements, completing the connections after the new structure had settled.

With the aim of humanizing the high-rise, the building is organized as a series of “vertical villages” connected by atria and outdoor terraces. To allow for future change, floors above and below the atria are designed to be removed post-occupancy if tenants want to extend their “village.” With bolted connec­tions, the flex floors can be disassembled and taken down the service elevator.

The building’s mixed-use, three-level podium, with a market hall and publicly accessible rooftop park, is aimed at re-energizing the surrounding neighborhood. “Adaptive reuse is also a form of urban sustainability,” says Sydney-based 3XN partner Fred Holt. He describes a devolution in which assets age and lose value, owners stop investing, the district deteriorates, attracting less attention and investment from the municipality, and new builds start to push toward cities’ outer edges, where infrastruc­ture must then be extended, emitting yet more carbon. “QQT’s adaptive reuse allowed us to reinvigorate not only an asset that was losing value,” he says, “but also an existing precinct within the city, thus reducing indi­rect CO2 from further expansion.”

A similar rationale of conservation through minimization underpinned ZGF’s proposal to upgrade what was initially intended only as a swing space on the Los Angeles campus of California State University. An eight-story, 218,000-square-foot vacant laboratory building had been damaged in the 1994 Northridge earthquake, and the university’s original brief envisioned a seismic retrofit, hazardous-materials abatement, and new finishes to accommodate an administrative and student-services center just until a new building could be completed: at that point the former lab building would be demolished.

PHOTOGRAPHY: © GENSLER/RYAN GOBUTY

PHOTOGRAPHY: © DAVID LAUER

AS PART of a transformation of a vacant telecom building (top) in Denver into office space, Gensler has replaced its Brutalist cladding with a new facade (above).

Instead, ZGF proposed that, by investing in a more comprehensive renovation, the university could eliminate the need for a new building, and the cost of demolition and time, money, materials, and effort would not be wasted on a temporary space. “Five or six years ago, embodied carbon was not on many people’s radar,” says Amy Leedham, an archi­tect in the San Francisco office of Atelier Ten, the project’s environmental consultant, “but even if we weren’t using that term, implicitly we all understood that salvaging this building for a good long-term use would be an embodied-carbon win.”

In addition to the seismic retrofit, scope for the new Administrative and Student Services Building, completed in 2021, included new windows, roofing, building services and controls, and security, as well as interior configuration, finishes, fixtures, and equip­ment, with a series of studies by Atelier Ten and ZGF guiding the major moves. The first set of analyses, conducted during schematic design, informed the facade design. Another set early in design development focused on interior design recommendations to optimize daylight, and a final set at the end of con­struc­­tion quantified the total achievement. “One of the challenges that’s unique to adaptive reuse is meaningful operational improvements,” says Leedham. “Without a complete re-skin and mechanical-system upgrade, embodied-carbon savings may not make up the loss from operational compro­mises over the life of the building. But here we have the best of both.”

A life cycle assessment (LCA) uses scientifically validated methods to tally resource inputs and emissions—to air, soil, and water—and to quantify a project’s overall environmental loads from cradle to gate, or cradle to grave, depending on the type of analysis undertaken. (Among the reasons a team might choose one method over another is the fact that popular third-party certifications, such as LEED and the Living Building Chal­lenge, have different requirements.) The Cal State renovation’s LCA reveals that, over a 60-year period, the adaptive reuse will reduce the building’s total carbon by 37 percent com­pared to code-compliant new construction. Over that period, the embodied carbon of the renovation, which includes core and shell elements but not MEP (a scope which is still difficult to capture, due to a lack of manufac­turer transparency), accounts for 22 percent of the building’s total carbon footprint. Shorten the period to 20 years, however, and embodied carbon’s share shoots up to almost half, reiter­ating its importance in achieving near-term emissions reduction goals. In another analysis of the project’s conservation achievement, operational savings recouped the embodied carbon of the renovation in two years; an equiv­alent new building would have taken 10.

In the five or so years since the CSULA renovation was designed, awareness of em­bod­ied carbon and the ability to measure it has improved. “If we were doing it now, we would probably do significant interior-finish analysis during design development,” says Leedham. “Five years ago, there wasn’t enough data transparency from manufacturers to be able to do that, but now for primary interior-finish materials, there definitely is—though more advancement in transpar­ency will only make the process easier.”

The ease with which it’s now possible to perform life-cycle assessments was a key take­­away from Gensler’s transformation of a 12-story, 230,000-square-foot vacant telecom building into a contemporary workplace on a corner lot in downtown Denver, says Alex Garrison, design director at the firm’s local office. Big moves in the renovation of the Link, as the building is known, included replacing its Brutalist concrete panels and ribbon windows with high-performance glazing and operable windows, cladding the first two stories with stone, and creating tenant-ready interiors with concrete floors, open ceilings, and an array of amenities. Datum lines that relate to adjacent historic buildings help stitch the Link into its context, and the building’s new ground-level retail, café, conference center, and lobby are re-animating the neighborhood.

ONE ANALYSIS conducted for the LCA of Gensler’s Denver renovation compares the embodied footprints of new construction and adaptive reuse and the relative contribution of each material.

Gensler conducted an LCA of the com­pleted project to quantify its embodied-carbon achievement. The aim was to provide a basis for conversations with clients, munici­palities, and business associations about the signifi­cance and opportunity of adaptive reuse.

The LCA tool “is like a force multiplier,” says Garrison, describing the ease with which he was able to compare materials and generate analyses. “It makes you much more effective.” With a BIM plug-in (Tally) that uses a cus­tom-designed database combining material attrib­utes, assembly details, and architectural speci­fi­­cations with environmen­tal-impact data, Garrison calculated the embodied-carbon foot­print of the Link’s architectural compo­nents—curtain wall and enclosure, structure, thermal and moisture protection, masonry, and finishes—at about 2,165 tons of carbon dioxide equivalents (CO2e), a 68 percent reduction in embodied carbon compared with a baseline new build’s 6,750 tons. The most substantial savings came from the reuse of the steel-and-concrete structure.

“It’s opening people’s eyes to the potential to reimagine these old buildings,” says Garrison, “and it’s got clients thinking about older buildings in their portfolios or buildings that may be targets for acquisition.”

In addition to the fee-based tool that Gensler used, a number of alternatives are freely available. Buro Happold has developed the Buildings and Habitats object Model (BHoM) Life Cycle Assessment Toolkit, free, open-source software that won a 2020 AIA Innovation Award. It enables users to access BIM data from a variety of programs, move the data into other software environments, such as a visual programming tool or a spread­­sheet, and export the results to visual­ization engines or databases. “It provides transparency in terms of what the tool is doing, and flexibility in terms of where we draw data from and the environmental prod­uct declarations that we put into it,” says Rastetter, “but it does require some level of experience with programming tools.”

Another free tool is the Embodied Carbon in Construction Calculator (EC3), developed with input from some 50 industry partners and administered by the nonprofit Building Transparency (which now also administers Tally). EC3 draws on a database of thousands of third-party-verified Environmental Prod­uct Declarations (EPDs), enabling teams to compare the embodied carbon of alternative products, and to evaluate projects’ embodied emissions based on material quantities from construction estimates or BIM. Building Transparency is in the process of integrating this database with Tally’s, although EC3 will continue as a stand-alone product, especially useful for project teams that don’t rely on BIM, or on the particular BIM software with which Tally is compatible.

The greater the portion of an existing asset that can be incorporated into a redevelopment, the greater the conservation of embodied ener­gy, but even retaining just the below-grade structure can reduce the concrete needed for a new building by a significant amount—as much as 25 percent, suggests 3XN’s Holt. The new superstructure will typically provide a larger floor area, but those existing below grade levels may well be adequate as cities worldwide cut back on parking requirements. In whole or in part, reusing buildings that are past their functional prime, but whose materials are still viable, offers the potential for dramatic savings in building-sector emissions over the next 10 crucial years. As Quay Quar­ter Tower, CSULA’s Administra­tive and Student Services Building, and the Link illustrate, “upcycling the majority of the struc­ture of an existing building expresses an innovative vision for sustainable building in dense urban areas,” says Holt, “one that sets an example for devel­opers and city builders across the globe.”

Supplemental Materials:

Bringing Embodied Carbon Upfront: Coordinated action for the building and construction sector to tackle embodied carbon,
© World Green Building Council, September 2019. (Through page 13)

ARCHITECTURAL RECORD Architectural Record is the #1 source for design news, architect continuing education, and info on sustainability, houses, projects, and architectural products.

 

[ Page 2 of 2 ]  previous page Page 1 Page 2
Originally published in Architectural Record
Originally published in February 2022


Notice

Academies